Dan Froomkin | The Intercept | 31 July 2014
I don’t want to understate how seriously wrong it is that the CIA searched Senate computers. Our constitutional order is seriously out of whack when the executive branch acts with that kind of impunity — to its overseers, no less.
But given everything else that’s been going on lately, the single biggest — and arguably most constructive — thing to focus on is how outrageously CIA Director John Brennan lied to everyone about it.
“As far as the allegations of the CIA hacking into Senate computers, nothing could be further from the truth,” Brennan told NBC’s Andrea Mitchell in March. “We wouldn’t do that. I mean, that’s just beyond the, you know, the scope of reason in terms of what we do.”
Earlier, he had castigated “some members of the Senate” for making “spurious allegations about CIA actions that are wholly unsupported by the facts.” He called for an end to “outbursts that do a disservice to the important relationship that needs to be maintained between intelligence officials and Congressional overseers.”
And what compelled Senate intelligence committee chairwoman Dianne Feinstein to make a dramatic floor speech in the first place, bringing everything out in the open, was that Brennan had responded to her initial concerns not by acknowledging the CIA’s misconduct — but by firing back with an allegation of criminal activity by her own staff.
Not coincidentally, the document the CIA was hunting for, that Senate staffers were accused of purloining, and that Brennan was now lying about, was a big deal precisely because it exposed more lies.
Known as the Panetta Review (evidently prepared for Leon Panetta, who served as CIA director from 2009 to 2011), it became relevant last year, when the CIA started pushing back against many of the scathing conclusions in the several-thousand page “Torture Report” the Senate staffers had finished up in December 2012.
Even as the CIA was officially rebutting key parts of the committee’s report, the staffers realized they had an internal CIA review that corroborated them. In other words, it was proof that the CIA was now lying.
So what’s in the Torture Report? Well, I can’t quote from it, because the intelligence community and the White House have done such a good job of delaying its public release (although a redacted version is widely rumored to be coming soon).
But by all accounts, the report not only discloses abuse that was more brutal, systematic and widespread than generally recognized, but also chronicles how the people most intimately involved in the torture regime lied to others inside the CIA, lied to Justice Department lawyers, and lied to the public; how they lied about what they were doing, they lied to make it sound like it accomplished something, and afterwards, they lied some more.
Brennan reportedly told Feinstein and intelligence committee vice chairman Saxby Chambliss on Tuesday that he was sorry. But it’s hardly the first time he’s been caught in the act. There was, for instance, that time in June 2011, when he was President Obama’s counter-terrorism advisor, that he asserted that over the previous year there had not been a single collateral death from drone strikes. (He later amended that to say there was no “credible evidence” of such deaths.)
But there was indeed ample and credible evidence. (Just as one example, a March 2011 CIA drone attack in Pakistan killed some 50 people, including tribal elders who were gathered for a tribal conclave.)
Brennan’s erstwhile boss, Director of National Intelligence James Clapper, famously lied when he assured the Senate intelligence committee that the government wasn’t collecting data on Americans in bulk when, as it turns out, it was.
Lying, of course, has always been a problem in Washington. But especially after the 9/11 terror attacks, the Bush-Cheney regime took lying to new post-Nixon heights. Maybe even pre-Nixon.
When I sat down to write my last “White House Watch” column for the Washington Post, what struck me most about the Bush years were the lies. The most consequential, of course, were the lies about the war. The most telling were the lies to cover up the lies about the war. And the most grotesque were the lies about torture.
The other thing is that there were no consequences. No one got in trouble for lying. The only semi-casualty was Scooter Libby, briefly convicted of lying while obstructing the investigation into vice president Cheney’s lies.
Figuring out how to right the constitutional imbalance between the branches of government, as exposed by this CIA assault on Congress, is very complicated.
But doing something about lying isn’t. You need to hold people accountable for it.
History will assuredly record that President Obama lied about a number of things, particularly as he carried water for the intelligence community and the military. But he’s no Cheney.
So if you’re the president, you fire everyone who lies. Starting with John Brennan.
Related articles:
Daily Beast – 12 hours ago
Unlike the president, a long-awaited Senate report won’t use the word ‘torture’ to describe the CIA’s interrogations. But it will show horrific, systematic, and widespread abuse. The White House is set to give Congress on Friday the final, declassified version of …
CNN (blog) – 9 hours ago
n. a pause to assess the state, progress or condition of the political news cycle. BREAKING … TEMPORARY MIDEAST CEASE-FIRE: U.N. Secretary-General Ban Ki-moon and Secretary of State John Kerry say the U.N. hasassurances that all parties have …
The Atlantic – 10 hours ago
The agency spied on a congressional investigation into the torture of prisoners, then claimed it hadn’t. Conor Friedersdorf Jul 31 2014, 5:02 PM ET. Tweet. More. Email. Print. Jason Reed/Reuters. Senator Mark Udall, a member of the committee that conducts …
Reuters – 13 hours ago
WASHINGTON (Reuters) – The CIA conceded on Thursday that it had improperly monitored computers used by the U.S. Senate Intelligence Committee in an investigation of interrogation tactics and secret prisons for terrorism suspects after the Sept. 11, 2001 …
New York Daily News – 14 hours ago
WASHINGTON — The nation’s chief spook has done a very public 180-degree turn and apologized for snooping on a congressional committee, it was disclosed Thursday. CIA Director John Brennan admitted to leaders of the Senate Intelligence Committee …
Wall Street Journal – 14 hours ago
Central Intelligence Agency officers improperly accessed computers used by a Senate committee investigating the agency’s interrogation program. WSJ’s Siobhan Gorman discusses on the News Hub with Tanya Rivero. Photo: Getty Images.
CBC.ca – 15 hours ago
CIA Director John Brennan apologized to Senate intelligence committee leaders after his inspector general found that CIA employees acted improperly when the CIA searched Senate computers earlier this year. At the centre of the allegations is a computer …
The Guardian – 16 hours ago
Private apologies are not enough for a defender of torture, the architect of America’s drone program and the most talented liar in Washington. The nation’s top spy needs to go. Plus: CIA admits to spying on Senate staffers. john brennan cartoon. This is not the …
Independent Online – 16 hours ago
Senator Dianne Feinstein, chair of the Senate Intelligence Committee, speaks on Capitol Hill in Washington. File picture: J. Scott Applewhite. Washington – The CIA conceded on Thursday that it had improperly monitored computers used by the US Senate …
The Seattle Times – 16 hours ago
For months, CIA Director John Brennan stood firm in his insistence that the CIA had little to be ashamed of after searching the computers of the Senate Intelligence Committee. His defiant posture quickly collapsed after a devastating report by his own inspector …
Fox Business – 16 hours ago
FILE – This March 11, 2014 file photo shows CIA Director John O. Brennan speaking in Washington. The CIA’s insistence that it did not spy on its Senate overseers collapsed July 31 with the release of a stark report by the agency’s internal watchdog …
Economic Times – 17 hours ago
WASHINGTON: The chief of the CIA today apologised for the US spy agency’s surveillance of computers used by lawmakers and their staffers involved in investigating the organisation’s harsh interrogation techniques. In a statement, the CIA said its …
iAfrica.com – 18 hours ago
Lawmakers slammed the CIA on Thursday after the US intelligence agency admitted its officers had “improperly” spied upon Senate investigators probing allegations of torture. The CIA Director John Brennan has apologized to the head of the Senate Select …
Washington Post – Jul 31, 2014
CIA employees improperly searched computers used by Senate investigators involved in a multi-year probe of the agency’s use of harsh interrogation measures on terrorism suspects, according to the findings of an internal agency inquiry that prompted CIA …
Daily News & Analysis – 19 hours ago
The State Department has endorsed the broad conclusions of a harshly critical Senate report on the CIA’s interrogation and detention practices after the September 11, 2001 attacks against the US, a report that accuses the agency of brutally treating terror …
NDTV – 20 hours ago
Washington: CIA Director John Brennan is apologising to Senate intelligence committee leaders after his top investigator found that CIA employees acted improperly when the CIA searched Senate computers earlier this year. Agency spokesman Dean Boyd …
NDTV – 20 hours ago
Washington: An internal investigation by the Central Intelligence Agency has found that its officers penetrated a computer network used by the Senate Intelligence Committee in preparing its damning report on the CIA’s detention and interrogation program.
ABC Online – 21 hours ago
The director of America’s Central Intelligence Agency is being called on to resign today after it was revealed that his officers improperly accessed a computer network used by congressional staff. The staff were preparing what’s expected to be a damning report …
Christian Science Monitor – 21 hours ago
The Central Intelligence Agency improperly accessed Senate intelligence committee computers earlier this year, according to a summary of a CIA inspector general report describing the results of an internal investigation.
Fox News (blog) – 21 hours ago
Watch the latest video at FoxNews.com. Thursday, Greta Van Susteren went Off the Record to discuss CIA Director John Brennan’s apology for his agency’s admitted spying on the US Senate. “That is a crime, and a big one,” she said, saying that she smelled …
Chicago Tribune – 22 hours ago
Reporting from Washington—. The CIA acknowledged Thursday that its employees had secretly searched Senate computer files related to an investigation of the agency’s Bush-era harsh interrogation program, apologized to key senators and abandoned its …
Sky News Australia – Jul 31, 2014
The head of the CIA has apologised to US politicians after an investigation confirmed claims that his officers had ‘improperly’ accessed Senate computers, the agency says. In March, CIA Director John Brennan dismissed allegations the agency had spied on …
DAWN.com – Jul 31, 2014
WASHINGTON: The State Department has endorsed the broad conclusions of a harshly critical Senate report on the CIA’s interrogation and detention practices after the 9/11 attacks that accuses the agency of brutally treating terrorism suspects and …
New York Times – Jul 31, 2014
WASHINGTON — An internal investigation by the C.I.A. has found that its officers penetrated a computer network used by the Senate Intelligence Committee in preparing its damning report on the C.I.A.’s detention and interrogation program. The report by the …
Huffington Post – Jul 31, 2014
WASHINGTON — Following reports that Central Intelligence Agency employees improperly accessed computers used by U.S. Senate staff to investigate the agency, Sen. Mark Udall (D-Colo.) on Thursday called for the resignation of John Brennan as CIA …
New York Times – Jul 31, 2014
In March, John Brennan, the C.I.A. director, was indignant when Senator Dianne Feinstein charged that the agency had broken into computers used by staff investigators from the Senate Intelligence Committee, which she leads. “As far as the allegations of …
Irish Examiner – Jul 31, 2014
Former secretary of state Colin Powell was eventually told about the programme and sat in on meetings. Picture: AP. A US Senate report on the CIA’s interrogation and detention practices after the September 11, 2001, terror attacks on the US has concluded …
USA TODAY – Jul 31, 2014
In March, when Senate Intelligence Committee Chairman Dianne Feinstein, D-Calif., angrily charged the CIA with breaking into Senate computers, CIA Director John Brennan flatly denied it. “Nothing could be further from the truth,” Brennan said during an …
New Zealand Herald – Jul 31, 2014
WASHINGTON (AP) The CIA’s insistence that it did not spy on its U.S. Senate overseers collapsed Thursday with the release of a stark report by the agency’s internal watchdog documenting improper computer surveillance and obstructionist behavior by CIA …
Salt Lake Tribune – Jul 31, 2014
Intelligence » Report defused a rare public feud between the CIA and one of its oversight committees in Congress. By David Lerman. | Bloomberg News. First Published Jul 31 2014 05:59 pm • Updated 8 hours ago. Washington • CIA Director John Brennan …
